Due to a recent Supreme Court (SC) Judgement regarding part-year and zero-hour workers, we wanted to let you know there is now a significant change in how the calculation of holiday pay is undertaken and paid. I will try to keep this as simple as I can below, however should you have any further questions please do let us know.
So, what has changed and what could this mean for you?
Preferential payments to creditors are deemed as ‘preference’. In simple terms, this is when one creditor has intentionally been paid before (in preference to) another.
One example we have come across often is that directors tend to pay amounts which they have personally guaranteed with company funds, while leaving unsecured creditors unpaid.
The transfer of assets can also be seen as preference; this creditor is in a better financial position than another and this is therefore grounds for a misfeasance claim.
An example of how this could affect an irregular worker is as follows:
Unfortunately, it is not uncommon for assets to be transferred over to third parties by directors.
This is used as an attempt at protecting the assets once the company enters insolvency proceedings, but it often has the opposite effect!
An example we have seen many times is the transfer of an asset to a family member or trusted friend.
Disposing of an asset in this way is classed as misfeasance, not least because it has been transferred at less than market value.
What must I include when calculating average weekly earnings?
Other ways of concealing company assets includes shipping them overseas.
Intentionally placing assets out of reach of creditors in any way will be seen as misfeasance, because liquidators are bound to place creditor’s interests at the forefront of priorities.
What if my employee only ever works the same weekly hours and receives nothing of the above?
While there is nothing wrong with a company director taking a high salary or dividends when the company is in a profitable position, continuing to do so once the company has gone downhill or into insolvency will be classed as misfeasance.
Any director should be living within the means of their company; again, unauthorised loans or dividends will not be looked upon sympathetically.
How far can I go back to find the last 52 weeks worked?
As the director of a company you are responsible for being aware of your company’s financial situation; at the first sign of financial decline, action should be taken as soon as possible to resolve the situation.
This inherent director’s responsibility is the reason for the majority of misfeasance claims – creditors’ losses are seen as the fault of the director of the insolvent company.
What if I can only find less than 52 weeks?
As the director of a company you are responsible for being aware of your company’s financial situation; at the first sign of financial decline, action should be taken as soon as possible to resolve the situation.
This inherent director’s responsibility is the reason for the majority of misfeasance claims – creditors’ losses are seen as the fault of the director of the insolvent company.
What if my employee wants to take off less than a week?
As the director of a company you are responsible for being aware of your company’s financial situation; at the first sign of financial decline, action should be taken as soon as possible to resolve the situation.
This inherent director’s responsibility is the reason for the majority of misfeasance claims – creditors’ losses are seen as the fault of the director of the insolvent company.
So, what next?
- Contact us to discuss if you have any employees on zero hours or other irregular working agreements.
- Please ensure you keep accurate records of working hours and pay for all employees as this is essential for accurate holiday calculations.
- Moving forward, please consider your contractual options to avoid unworked weeks that will accrue holiday earnings.
- Take care before you terminate employees who are working for you as irregular workers as we may need to help you develop a plan to minimise your risk and costs.
The issue with this judgement is that it is dreadfully unfair for people who work regular weekly hours as someone with the same average earnings who works every week in the last year would now be paid the same as someone who may have only worked a couple of weeks in the last year as the calculation is based on the average weekly earnings.
The SC acknowledge it is unfair but states it is not a valid reason to not pass this judgement, as they want to ensure all employees receive the 5.6-week entitlement and accept that the Working Time Directive is flawed on this matter, but they do not have the power to change it.
This new judgement could not have been reasonably anticipated by any of us due to the ACAS guidance which was only changed following the SC judgement. Instead, we need to now support the best way forward for your business.
